Last Updated on January 6, 2024 by Ossian Muscad
Running a company requires regular evaluation of its current performance to ensure it’s on the right track. At the same time, the findings of this evaluation will provide key recommendations that will streamline corporate governance and determine gaps that need attention.
This evaluation is called an internal audit. The company’s audit department conducts this procedure periodically to optimize and improve business operations. Through this process, any areas of concern or issues can be identified and addressed before they become major problems.
An internal audit also mitigates potential risks across the enterprise and identifies areas of improvement to reach company goals. But what exactly is an internal audit, and how can you create a checklist tailored to your company’s audit needs?
This article will discuss the importance of an internal audit and how to create an internal audit checklist for your company. We will go through the essential steps and key elements to include in your checklist and provide insights on how to effectively conduct an internal audit.
What is an Internal Audit?
An Internal Audit is an independent, objective assurance and consulting activity designed to add value and improve an organization’s operations. It’s an evaluative process conducted internally or by an independent firm to assess the effectiveness of a company’s risk management, control, and governance processes.
The main objective of internal auditing is to enhance and protect organizational value by providing risk-based and objective assurance, advice, and insight. The areas covered in an internal audit can span across the organization’s financial, operational, and managerial processes, depending on the company’s audit plan. By identifying the areas of risk and offering recommendations for improvements, internal audits contribute significantly to a company’s growth and sustainability.
Internal Audit Vs. External Audit: What’s the Difference?
Internal and external audits are two ends of the spectrum when it comes to evaluating business operations. One focuses on the company’s internal workings, while the other focuses on its financial statements. The following sections will break down the main differences between internal and external audits:
Scope of the Audit
- Internal Audit: The scope of an internal audit is determined internally and can vary depending on the needs and goals of the organization. It can cover many areas, such as operational effectiveness, risk management, and internal controls.
- External Audit: An external audit primarily focuses on the financial statements of an organization. Statutory and regulatory requirements determine its scope, and it aims to provide assurance that the financial information presented by the company is fair, accurate, and in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.
Conducted by
- Internal Audit: Internal audits are conducted by a company’s internal audit department or by an external consultant engaged by the company.
- External Audit: External audits are conducted by independent auditors who are not employees of the company, providing a third-party perspective on the company’s financial statements.
Purpose and Outcome
- Internal Audit: An internal audit’s primary purpose is to improve organizational processes. The outcome is a set of recommendations for improvements and risk mitigation strategies.
- External Audit: The main purpose of an external audit is to provide credibility to the company’s financial statements. The outcome is an auditor’s report expressing an opinion on the fairness of the financial statements.
Despite each audit type serving different purposes, they both play a crucial role in ensuring the success and sustainability of an organization. By understanding the differences between these audits, companies can better prioritize their audit needs and develop effective checklists for each method.
Benefits of a Successful Internal Audit
The benefits of a successful internal audit are manifold and can significantly impact a company’s overall performance and growth. Implementing a robust internal audit system can unlock avenues for improvements, risk mitigation, and compliance with regulations. Let’s dive deeper and explore five notable benefits of an effective internal audit.
Enhanced Operational Efficiency
A successful internal audit provides valuable feedback on a business’s operational processes. This feedback identifies inefficiencies and suggests improvement measures, leading to enhanced productivity and operational efficiency. As a result, companies can streamline their operations and reduce overall costs.
Improved Risk Management
A comprehensive internal audit identifies potential risks hiding within the operations. Early detection enables companies to preemptively develop and implement risk mitigation strategies, improving overall risk management. That way, companies can protect themselves from fraud, legal issues, and compliance failures.
Increased Financial Reliability
Internal audits scrutinize a company’s financial processes, ensuring the accuracy and reliability of financial reports. Knowing that the financial statements are accurate and reliable increases trust and confidence among shareholders, stakeholders, and potential investors. It also helps companies comply with financial reporting regulations.
Ensured Regulatory Compliance
With their rigorous evaluation of processes and controls, internal audits ensure that a company complies with relevant regulations and standards. Through recommendations, companies can identify gaps in compliance and develop strategies to mitigate risks and ensure regulatory compliance. This helps avoid regulatory penalties and protects the company’s reputation.
Fostered Continuous Improvement
An effective internal audit fosters a culture of continuous improvement within an organization. By consistently identifying areas of improvement, it encourages change and innovation, leading to sustainable business growth. At the same time, regular audits provide a feedback loop, allowing companies to track progress and measure the impact of previous recommendations.
What is an Internal Audit Checklist?
An internal audit checklist is a tool that guides auditors through the steps of an audit. It’s common in different industries, including manufacturing, service sectors, and more, to assess if the organization’s current performance and processes meet certain requirements. The checklist should meet the specific needs of the company, and it can include items such as reviews of financial reports, interviews with employees, and evaluations of information technology infrastructure.
By using an internal audit checklist, you can make sure all areas of the organization are scrutinized. The list should cover different aspects, such as compliance with applicable laws and regulations, quality management, risk management, and more. Each item must be carefully reviewed so that nothing gets missed.
Why is an Internal Audit Checklist Important?
An internal audit checklist is essential for several reasons. It ensures that each audit is conducted systematically and consistently and provides a framework that can be referenced throughout the process.
Consistency Across Audits
With an internal audit checklist, every audit uses the same criteria. This consistency allows for easy comparison between different audits or sections of the organization, making it easier to identify trends, patterns, and areas for improvement.
Comprehensive Coverage
An internal audit checklist ensures that no area of the organization is overlooked during the audit. This comprehensive coverage is vital for identifying potential risks and vulnerabilities throughout the enterprise.
Facilitates Communication
A well-structured checklist serves as a communication tool between auditors and stakeholders. It clarifies the audit’s scope, processes, and expectations, fostering transparency and trust.
Efficiency in the Audit Process
An audit checklist enhances efficiency by reducing the time and effort in planning and conducting audits. It provides auditors with a clear roadmap, eliminating guesswork and promoting timely completion of the audit.
An internal audit checklist acts as the backbone of an effective audit process. The key is customizing it to fit your organization’s unique needs and requirements. Remember, the more detailed your checklist, the more effective your audit will be.
Items to Include in an Internal Audit Checklist
The items in an internal audit checklist should outline the entire audit process, from planning to completion. By putting all of the essential elements of an audit in one convenient list, you’ll be able to go through every step of the audit process without missing anything.
Not only does it streamline the audit process, but it also ensures consistency and accuracy. With that said, here are some items to include in an internal audit checklist, separated by the different stages of an audit.
1. Initial Audit Planning
- Identify the scope and objectives of the audit, including the specific areas and processes to be examined and the goals to be achieved.
- Establish a comprehensive audit timeline, outlining key milestones and deadlines to ensure timely completion of the audit.
- Gather detailed information about the area to be audited, including relevant documents, records, and data sources, to support a thorough and effective examination.
- Develop a preliminary audit program that outlines the audit procedures, techniques, and methodologies to be employed, ensuring a structured and systematic approach to the audit process.
2. Involve Risk and Process Subject Matter Experts
- To ensure a comprehensive audit, it is essential to involve subject matter experts in risk management and process controls.
- Before conducting the audit, it is crucial to discuss the potential risks associated with the specific area to be audited.
- By leveraging expert insights, you can refine the audit program and ensure that all relevant risks are addressed effectively.
3. Frameworks for Internal Audit Process
- It is important for organizations to adopt suitable internal audit frameworks such as COSO (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) and COBIT (Control Objectives for Information and Related Technologies) to ensure effective governance and risk management.
- When implementing an internal audit framework, aligning it with the company’s objectives and regulatory requirements is crucial. This ensures the framework supports the organization’s strategic goals and addresses compliance obligations.
- Additionally, organizations should customize the chosen framework to cater to their unique needs. This involves adapting the framework to the organization’s size, industry, and specific risk profile, enabling a more tailored and effective internal audit process.
4. Frameworks for Internal Audit Processes
- Embrace and modify audit methodologies, tools, and templates to enhance efficiency and effectiveness.
- Guarantee compliance with the standards established by professional organizations such as the IIA or AICPA.
- Integrate industry-leading practices to continuously improve audit processes and outcomes.
5. Initial Document Request List
- Identify the documents required for the audit, such as financial statements, invoices, contracts, and relevant policies.
- Request the necessary documents from the auditee well in advance, ensuring a sufficient timeline for preparation.
- Thoroughly review the obtained documents to understand the area to be audited, analyze the information, and identify potential risks or areas of concern.
6. Preparing for a Planning Meeting With Business Stakeholders
- Prepare a comprehensive agenda outlining the topics to be discussed and the desired outcomes of the meeting.
- Identify and invite key stakeholders with a direct interest or involvement in the matters to be addressed during the meeting.
- Prior to the meeting, proactively share the initial audit plan with the stakeholders to gather their insights and ensure alignment.
7. Preparing the Audit Program
Summary and Purpose of the Audit Program
- Establish the purpose of the audit, which is to assess the effectiveness and compliance of the organization’s internal controls and processes.
- Summarize the audit processes to be followed, including conducting interviews, reviewing documentation, performing tests, and analyzing data to gather evidence and evaluate the organization’s adherence to policies and procedures.
Process Objectives and Owners
- Clearly define and document the objectives of each business process to ensure clarity and alignment with organizational goals.
- Identify and assign owners to each process who will be responsible for its execution, monitoring, and continuous improvement. This ensures accountability and effective management of the processes.
Process Risks
- Identify and list all potential risks associated with each process, considering internal and external factors.
- Evaluate the potential impact and likelihood of each risk by analyzing historical data, industry standards, and expert opinions.
Controls Mitigating Process Risks
- Identify and document control measures that have been implemented to mitigate the identified risks.
- Conduct regular evaluations to assess the effectiveness of these controls in managing and reducing the identified risks.
Control Attributes
- Define the specific attributes and characteristics of each control measure, outlining their purpose and intended effects.
- Clearly articulate the procedures and methods for testing each control measure, ensuring accuracy and reliability in assessing their effectiveness.
Testing Procedures and Methods for Controls to be Tested During the Audit
- Establish clear and comprehensive procedures for testing each control to ensure effectiveness and accuracy.
- Carefully select testing methods that align perfectly with the audit objectives, taking into account the specific requirements and desired outcomes.
8. Audit Program and Planning Review
- Thoroughly review the audit program to ensure its completeness and identify potential areas for improvement.
- Carefully align the audit plan with the defined audit objectives and the overarching goals of the company.
- Once all necessary adjustments have been made, finalize the audit plan and promptly share it with all relevant stakeholders for their awareness and input.
How to Conduct an Internal Audit?
The process of conducting an internal audit requires meticulous planning and execution. This section will outline a comprehensive step-by-step guide on effectively conducting an internal audit in your organization. From the initial planning stage to the final reporting, we will provide you with all the essential information you need to conduct an efficient and thorough internal audit.
Step 1: Plan the Audit
Start by defining the scope of the audit. This involves identifying the areas to be audited, the audit criteria, and setting the time frame for the audit. During this phase, prepare your internal audit checklist, ensuring it is comprehensive and aligned with your organization’s objectives. A well-prepared checklist will streamline the auditing process and ensure all necessary aspects are covered.
Step 2: Gather Information
Once the planning phase is complete, gather all relevant documents and records. These might include financial statements, organizational charts, process diagrams, policies, procedures, and past reports. Ensuring that you have all the necessary information will contribute to the smooth and successful execution of the project. At the same time, it also helps identify potential areas of concern that may require further investigation.
Step 3: Conduct the Audit
Using your internal audit checklist, systematically review all identified areas and processes. This may involve interviewing staff, observing procedures, and verifying records and documents. Evaluating each area against the audit criteria is crucial to ensure standards are met. By doing so, you will identify any gaps or areas of concern that require further investigation.
Step 4: Document Findings
Record all findings during the audit process. This includes both areas of compliance and areas that need improvement or pose potential risks. The documentation should be detailed and clear, providing sufficient evidence to support each finding. Avoid using vague or subjective language, and ensure all information is accurate and well-supported.
Step 5: Report Audit Results
Compile a report detailing your findings, including any non-compliance or risk areas. Wherever possible, include recommendations for improvement. Present this report to management or relevant stakeholders to ensure they are aware of the audit results. Have an open discussion to address any concerns and agree on corrective actions where necessary.
Arwp 6: Implement Changes
Based on the audit findings, develop and implement an action plan to address any identified issues. Continuously track these changes to assess their impact and ensure they lead to the desired improvements. If necessary, conduct follow-up audits to verify the effectiveness of these changes.
Step 7: Follow-Up Audits
Schedule follow-up audits to review the effectiveness of the changes implemented. These audits ensure that improvements are maintained, and new issues have not arisen. So, keeping track of any changes and their impact on the organization is crucial. Consider conducting follow-up audits at regular intervals to continuously improve processes and maintain compliance.
How Can You Create an Internal Audit Checklist for Your Company?
Now that you know what contents to include in an internal audit checklist, it’s time to know how to create one. Then, the audit team must brainstorm and assess which areas need checking to make their lives easier.
Creating an internal audit checklist is as simple as listing all the essential things you need to check. But if you want your list to be comprehensive, there are ten essential steps that you need to take to create an internal audit checklist for your company:
- Review the company’s policies and procedures. This will help you identify the areas that require auditing.
- Assess the company’s risk level. This will help you determine which areas need more attention during the audit.
- Tailor the checklist to meet the specific needs of the company. By doing so, you will ensure that all areas are covered.
- Include all the essential areas that need an audit. Don’t overlook any critical areas, even if they may seem insignificant.
- Check the company’s quality management system documentation. This system provides a framework for managing processes and ensuring compliance.
- Interview employees to get their insights on the company’s operations. Knowing their concerns and observations can provide valuable insights during the audit.
- Evaluate the company’s information technology infrastructure. This information is essential to ensure data security and integrity.
- Assess how well the company’s processes are being implemented. As an internal auditor, it is crucial to identify any gaps in the implementation of processes and procedures.
- Evaluate the company’s performance against the standard. Look for any discrepancies or non-compliance and document them accordingly.
- Make recommendations for improvement. Once the audit is complete, provide recommendations to help the company address any issues and continuously improve processes.
An internal audit checklist is vital to help companies assess their current performance and processes. By using a checklist, companies can ensure that all areas they cover improve the quality of audits.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: What is the role of an internal audit checklist in risk management?
An internal audit checklist plays a pivotal role in risk management by identifying potential areas of non-compliance, operational inefficiencies, or other risks. It aids in the systematic examination of processes and operations within the organization and highlights areas that need improvement, thus helping in risk mitigation.
Q2: How often should I update my internal audit checklist?
The frequency of updates to an internal audit checklist depends on the dynamic nature of your organization’s operations and regulatory environment. Typically, it should be updated whenever there are significant changes in processes or regulations or after every audit cycle to incorporate learnings from the previous one.
Q3: Can I use the same internal audit checklist for all departments in my organization?
Though some key elements may be common, it’s recommended to customize the internal audit checklist based on the unique operations and risks associated with each department. This ensures all relevant points are considered during the audit process.
Q4: Who should be involved in creating an internal audit checklist?
While it is primarily the responsibility of the audit team, involvement from management and department heads can add valuable insights. This cross-functional collaboration ensures that the checklist covers all aspects of operations.
Q5: What are the key components of an effective internal audit checklist?
An effective internal audit checklist should include a review of policies, risk assessment, process implementation, IT infrastructure, quality management documentation, and company performance against set standards. Employee insights should also be considered.
Q6: How detailed should the internal audit checklist be?
The depth of detail in an internal audit checklist should balance thoroughness and usability. While covering all essential aspects is crucial, an overly detailed checklist can become cumbersome and may dilute attention from key risk areas. Aim for a checklist that is comprehensive yet succinct.
Streamline Your Internal Audits with DATAMYTE
DATAMYTE is a quality management platform with low-code capabilities. Our Digital Clipboard, in particular, is a low-code workflow automation software that features a workflow, checklist, and smart form builder. This tool lets you create customized checklists to streamline internal audits and manage quality processes efficiently.
DATAMYTE also lets you conduct layered process audits, a high-frequency evaluation of critical process steps, focusing on areas with the highest failure risk or non-compliance. Conducting LPA with DATAMYTE lets you effectively identify and correct potential defects before they become major quality issues.
With DATAMYTE, you have an all-in-one solution for quality process and audit management. From building customizable checklists to conducting audits to reporting, our platform helps you save time and resources while ensuring compliance with standards and regulations. Book a demo now to learn more.
Conclusion
An internal audit checklist is invaluable for companies to assess their performance, identify potential risks, and ensure compliance with various regulations. It provides a structured framework that covers all significant aspects, from company policies, risk levels, and quality management systems to IT infrastructure and process implementation.
The checklist should be tailored to meet the unique needs of the company and its specific departments, ensuring no crucial area is overlooked. Regular updates and improvements to your checklist can lead to more efficient audits and, ultimately, a stronger, more compliant organization.
Developing and utilizing an internal audit checklist isn’t just a smart move—it’s a strategic one that can significantly improve your operations, mitigate risks, and promote a culture of continual improvement.
